I have been looking into buying a new mattress for the last month or two. I started out looking at a local furniture store and really liking the tempur pedic cloud luxe but I just couldn’t justify spending 5K on a bed. So I started doing research online and I have now learned more then I really wanted to know about mattresses. With the help of this site and others I have learned how much the name brand mattresses are marked up and how inferior they are made. I came across the beducation videos and learned that the store they are from “mattress to go” is just a few miles away from where I live. I visited Jeff and was all set to purchase the Ecogel Blue Heaven but wanted to give it some thought before I buy. That is when I visited this forum and found Brooklyn Bedding and Dreamfoam. Now I feel like I am standing on a three sided fence and I need I little push to figure out witch mattress to purchase. I am hoping Phoenix and other members here can help educate me and help me determine the best fit for me.
The three mattresses I am trying to decide between are listed below. I am 6’3" and about 200 lb my wife is 5’10" and about 140lbs. We are both side sleepers and we are both tired of waking up with hip and lower back pain from out 10 year old spring mattress. The three mattresses I am trying to decide between are listed below. I have some concerns about each one and I am having a hard time trying to decide which one to try.
Dreamfoam Ultimate Dreams 13" Gel Memory Foam Mattress
https://www.amazon.com/DreamFoam-Mattress-Ultimate-Dreams-13-Inch/dp/B0092UCN0Y
3" of 4lb gel memory foam, 2" of 5lb memory foam, 8" base of premium base foam
Brooklyn Bedding 14" Aloe Adelle
http://www.brooklynbedding.com/memory-foam-mattresses/14-inch-aloe-memory-foam-mattress
3" of 4lb gel memory foam, 3" of Talalay latex and 7" of 2.17lb HD Omalon foam core
Therapedic Ecogel Memory Foam Blue Heaven
https://www.matt-to-go.com/Blue_Heaven.html
2" 5 lb. 15 IFD High-Support Open-Cell Memory Foam, DynaFlow Airlock System, 2" 4 lb. 12 IFD EcoGel Second Generation Gel Polymer Infused Memory Foam, 2" 24 ILD, 5.5 lb. Conform Talalay Latex, Non-Toxic Flame Retardant SafeGuard™ Fiber. 1" 2.0 lb. 18 IFD Latex-Enhanced Support Layer. Core: 6" Heavy Density 1.8 lb. Perfect Form Support Soy-Infused Core.
The Blue Heaven I was able to try out at Mattress to Go and it seemed a little firmer then other foam mattress I have tried. It is sold from a local store but does not have an exchange or trial period. I am also not sure if the multiple layers are better then just a couple of layers of foam in these other mattresses. The Ulitmate Dreams I found in this forum and it seems to have many good reviews written about it. But this one does not have any trial period either. This bothers me since I am unable to try it out and see how it feels before I buy. I have tried the tempur pedic cloud luxe at the local store and I really liked it and this mattress from what I have read is close to the same feel but maybe a little firmer. And finally the Aloe Adelle which I am not able to try out either but it does have a 120 day trial period. I also think the interchangeable layers are a unique feature but I’m not sure how practical they are or how much they actually will be changed. This mattress seems to be the biggest gamble since I have nothing to compare it to like I do with the Ultimate Dreams.
So I think it may come down to the quality of each mattress. Which one of these mattresses are a better quality construction and which uses better foam? I’m thinking the Ecogel may be better made since the foam is infused with gel but I may be off in left field some where and that is why I need your help. Can you help outline the strengths and weaknesses of each mattress listed or even recommend another choice if these one are not of good quality? How long should I expect these mattresses to last? Is the Ecogel really worth twice as much as the Ultimate Dreams and fifty percent more then the Aloe Adelle? The engineer in me is starting to take over and this search for a new mattress is starting to turn into what is feeling like a second job. So any help would be greatly appreciated.