Hi rhuntsman,
Just to add a little bit to S0L0’s great information.
The Brooklyn Bedding warranty is 10 years.
There are no returns on the Brooklyn bedding mattresses once you’ve opened them.
Some of the models on the Amazon site such as the EuroTop and their Total Latex mattress (as well as the new models they are now starting to roll out on their Brooklyn Bedding site) have a layer exchange option which means that you can exchange the comfort layer for a different softness/firmness level if your original choice is not quite right. The details of the layer exchange for the mattresses on the Amazon site is described here and for the mattresses on the Brooklyn Bedding site is described here. The Amazon site has 4 different latex or latex hybrid mattresses. The three hybrid models (a polyfoam base with a latex comfort layer) are the Ultra Plush, the Eurotop, and the Natural Latex (that uses wool and 100% natural Dunlop). The fourth is the Total Latex mattress which is all latex in both the comfort layer and the support core.
I’m not sure where you live in Idaho but there may be some retailers or manufacturers close to you that offer latex mattresses which could be useful as a reference point for testing at least. For example if you are close to Boise then post #2 here has some of the better local options I’m aware of including some that offer latex or latex hybrids. Post #4 here has a list in the Coeur d’Alene area.
A forum search on “Ultimate Dreams” (you can just click this) will bring up many more posts about them including feedback from many forum members.
All the manufacturing members of this site offer a 5% discount or a product bonus to the members of this forum (a forum “member” is anyone who has made at least one post here).
The mattresses on their Amazon site have a TMU bonus of a free shredded latex pillow. On the mattresses from the Brooklyn Bedding site members have a choice of either a 5% discount on the mattress or 2 free shredded latex pillows.
EDIT: To receive the forum discount on their Brooklyn Bedding line make sure you either call, email, or use their chat to get the discount information before your purchase.
Hope that helps.
Phoenix