Dear Phoenix,
First of all, just wanted to say thank you for creating and maintaining this amazing site. I’m the kind of person who likes to make purchases based on as much information as possible, and your site has been a huge help in my current search.
So here’s my situation: I’m looking to get my parents a memory foam mattress for Christmas in the $1000-1400 range. I know latex is generally your preference, but the good ones seem to be a bit on the pricey side for my budget, and I think my mom has a latex sensitivity anyway. Current mattress is a 20-year old innerspring with a pronounced sag, so pretty much anything will be a huge improvement! Anyway, my parents are in their 60s with some chronic pain issues - my mom has disintegrating discs in her back and related nerve pain in her leg, while my dad has a bad shoulder and some arthritis developing in his joints. Mom’s about 5’6’’ / 125 lbs., and Dad’s about 5’8" / 160 lbs. They both mix side sleeping and back sleeping. My mom likes the soft, cushiony feeling of a traditional pillow-top mattress, while my dad doesn’t like that feeling of sinking into the bed. They both sleep kind of hot, but they live in northern VT, so in the winter, their room can be a bit chilly.
Given all of that, I’m thinking a mattress with 4-5lb. a memory foam comfort layer (possibly with gel) and a quality support core (but let me know if you disagree), however, I’m having trouble deciding among the various options out there, particularly since there seems to be a significant price range even among the quality manufacturers/sellers. If you could offer some advice on the relevant differences among the mattresses on my short list (all from Mattress Underground’s members) and which you think might best suit my parents’ needs, I would really appreciate it. Here’s the short list (all queen size):
- Dreamfoam - Ultimate Dreams 13" Gel Memory Foam Mattress for $699: 3" of 4lb. memory foam & 2" of 5lb. memory foam over an 8" polyfoam support layer (cheapest option, but reluctant on this one because it has only a 30 day trial period instead of 90 days like the others)
- Sleep EZ - Memory Foam Mattress for $895: 3" of 5.5lb. Sensus memory foam over 6" polyfoam support layer
- Select Foam - Conform Select 10" for $1099: 3" of 5.3lb. gel memory foam over 7" polyfoam support layer
- Select Foam - Conform Signature 12" for $1399: 4" of 5.3lb. gel memory foam over 8" polyfoam support layer
- Select Foam - Cirrus Supreme-ES 11" for $1399: 2" of 4lb. memory foam & 2" of 5.3lb. gel memory foam over 7" polyfoam support layer
- Rocky Mountain Mattress - Sundance 10" for $760: 3" of 4lb. Bayer memory foam over 6" polyfoam support layer
- Rocky Mountain Mattress - Tamarack 12" for $1000: 2" of Bayer “super-soft” (IFD: 10) polyfoam & 3.3" of 4lb. Bayer memory foam over Bayer convoluted memory foam (2-3" I think) & lumbar support layer and 3.9" polyfoam support layer
- Rocky Mountain Mattress - Palisades 11" for $1130: 3" of 4lb. Bayer memory foam over a polyfoam support layer
- Rocky Mountain Mattress - Cool Comfort 10" for $1000: 2" of 4lb. Aerus memory foam & 2" of Sensus 5lb. memory foam over support layer comprised of 3" of 35 ILD polyfoam and 3" of 30 ILD polyfoam (the order of which can be switched)
- Rocky Mountain Mattress - Brighton 12" for $1260: 4" of 5lb. Bayer memory foam over Bayer polyfoam support layer
Thanks in advance for your input, Phoenix!