@downisthenewup87 Taking note of your sleep position, weight, height, and the various mattresses you’ve tried, we’d recommend going with the 4-lb memory foam topper. Our 3-inch TitanFlex topper is extremely responsive and feels very similar to latex, which could lead to sore spot feelings you mentioned experiencing. The 4-lb memory foam topper will contour to your body and provide pressure relief for those moments you end up on your side while sleeping, but won’t sacrifice the support you need when on your back. You can also choose between 2 and 3 inch heights with our 4-lb memory foam topper, with the 2 inch being slightly firmer than the 3 inch topper.
If you give either one a try, we have a 30-day return policy that begins on the day of delivery for a full refund. Keep us updated on which topper you choose and let us know if you have any additional questions!