Top Ranked Mattresses on Other Sites- I really need help

[phoenix]

Hi EZ4HZ,

I accidentally deleted my post I think.

The forum software keeps deleted posts until I permanently delete them so I can restore it if you’d like.

Im stick between christeli Madeline (cloud supreme breeze approximate) and dream foam supreme (cloud supreme app).

Feel of the mattress aside, in terms of the materials, densities, designs, and construction of the two would it seem that one is a clear winner and a better value for its price? Also if they were the same price would the Madeline be a clear winner as far a materials, design, construction method etc?

The Christeli uses higher quality/density materials, has edge support, has the flippable base, and is a higher price ($949).

The Dreamfoam uses gel memory foam in the top 1.5" layer and has a lower price ($599 - the 10% FB discount of $59.90 if you order from the Dreamfoam site = $539.10).

Christeli has a 40 day return policy and Dreamfoam has a 45 day return policy (again if you order from the Dreamfoam site) with a slightly higher cost involved if you decide to return it).

Both of them have a similar firmness level to the Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme/Supreme Breeze.

The higher density materials would make “some” difference in terms of durability and the useful life of the mattress but it would make a bigger difference for those that are in higher weight ranges.

When you are down to finalists that are choices between good and good and there are no clear winners between them then the final choice that is best for you will be a matter of “best judgement” based on all the objective, subjective, and intangible parts of your personal value equation that are most important to you (see post #2 here). There are no “bad” choices here.

The dreamfoam supreme only uses 4lb foam but has a much better price. I wanted to ask… How come dream foam made it to the list but christeli did not? Are dreamfoam beds just superior in de objective way that I’m not seeing or is it based on something else like transparency.

While I would certainly read something positive into the fact that a manufacturer is a member here (see here) and they are what make the time, effort, and research that goes into this site possible in the first place … I wouldn’t read anything negative into the fact that a manufacturer isn’t a member here and would assess their mattresses based on the mattresses themselves. I point to value wherever I see it and there are many manufacturers across the country that aren’t on the membership list … at least yet. When the site first started there were less than 10 members and there are many manufacturers and retailers that will be added to the membership over the course of coming years. Post #7 here and the posts it links to (near the bottom of the post) includes my comments in reply to the same question about some other manufacturers as well.

Phoenix