We have a 15 yr old king mattress with two 39x80 foundations (box springs). It is also a pillow top which was a mistake. The mattress definitely needs replacement but the foundation appears to be fine. The mattress is 10" and there is definitely an indentation.
Our plan is to replace the mattress with two twin XL and use the existing two box springs. This would allow the twin XL mattress to be rotated side to reduce sagging of edge support on one side only.
Initially, we will just replace the king mattress and keep the twin XLs together, even using the same sheets and blankets. In the near future, I will have two separate frames and each bed will be free standing. We have no plans for the concept of a split king with adjustable frame.
Now the big questions: (soft / medium firm / firm / ultra firm). As noted, my scale says #300.and I don’t like the sinking feelin and prefer more firmness. Does being heavy require more firmness? Will it make the mattress last longer?
Next, my assumption is a hybrid would be better for me. I’ve found the price ranges is significant. Will and expensive mattress be more comfortable or last longer"
There are dozens of products in a twin XL, here are low, median and high priced options that represent a snapshot of availability.
- A “Vesgantti” at $175. and replace it after a few years
- A “Plank” although all foam, the name suggest neiong like a board at $636.
- A “Satva” which has a pillow top that concerns me at $1,300
Any advice relative to my situation or suggestions welcome.
Hello Jim, and welcome!
It sounds like you’ve considered a few different options. To address a couple of your concerns, sometimes people find with a higher BMI, it is a good idea to go firmer with the mattress. As far as wear, to gauge how long a mattress might last - look at their guarantee and see how long it is. If only 3-5 years, then the mattress will not last as long, probably, as one that has a 10-20 year warranty.
Hope this helps and good luck with your search!
Katie for TCB
Given the three products I mentioned (and dozens more), Am I better off spending more on a high quality, higher priced product and hoping it last 10 years.?
Or buying a lower priced product and plan on replacing it every 2 or 3 yrs?
Opting for a higher quality product is more logical not solely for its potential decade-long lifespan, but because, throughout your ownership period, you’ll experience the benefits of superior, supportive, and durable materials, ultimately enhancing the comfort of your sleep.
This decision is entirely personal, as you’ll be spending an average of 6-8 hours per day on the mattress, ideally for many years to come.
While cost can be debated, there are mattresses with top-notch materials available at a reasonable price. It doesn’t necessarily have to be a $10,000 mattress. By making informed choices and seeking guidance from a committed mattress professional who collaborates with you to understand your preferences and comfort requirements, you can find a winning option.
I don’t intend to overshadow Katie’s insights, but it’s worth noting that many reputable mattress companies align the quality of their products and warranties, as Katie mentioned. Nevertheless, caution is essential, as some lower-cost alternatives may offer “lifetime” warranties without genuine intentions of honoring them.
Best of luck,
Maverick