Wondering if anyone has tried it. I love fiber mattresses, futons are great but a bit too firm now. Vispring is a little pricey, I can do a latex topper but not full latex, love wool, cotton and horsehair fiber. Could a futon be a bit more comfortable on top of a traditional spring box spring? I’m 58, female, 5’4", 155lbs. Luxury firm plus some cush is my jam.
Thank you for the time and help.
Lara
Using a futon on an old-fashioned box spring has both pros and cons.
Placing a futon on an old-fashioned box spring can evoke some similarities and differences compared to how mattresses were made from the mid to late 1900s.
During that period of time, many mattresses were built with a layered construction that included natural materials like cotton, wool, and sometimes horsehair, similar to the fiber components found in modern futons. Both setups often utilized a box spring for support, helping to absorb shock and provide a stable foundation. Additionally, like futons, many mattresses from that period were designed for versatility, often serving multiple functions in homes, particularly in smaller living spaces. These folks still make mattresses using the same equipment, materials and designs dating back more than 100 years
On the positive side, a futon, while typically used as a firm sleep surface, can work as an extra layer of cushioning, potentially enhancing comfort and support on a traditionally extra firm traditional box spring.
They are also quite flexible, easily folded and stored, making them a versatile option for smaller spaces. Futons tend to be more budget-friendly than traditional mattresses, allowing for a cost-effective solution. They come in a variety of styles and fabrics, which can help customize your bedding cosmetics, and they serve as a practical sleeping option for guests without taking up too much space.
However, there are some downsides to consider. Depending on the futon’s design, it may not provide the same level of support as a traditional mattress, particularly if it’s older or well-used. Futons are generally firmer than standard mattresses, which might not suit everyone’s comfort preferences. If the box spring is old, it may not offer adequate support, potentially affecting the futon’s performance and durability. Additionally, futons can retain heat depending on the fill of the futon, which may be uncomfortable for those who sleep hot, and they may not last as long as traditional mattresses, especially with frequent use.
While a futon on a box spring could be a good temporary solution, it’s important to consider whether it will meet your long-term comfort needs.
Remember, most traditional mattresses incorporated an innerspring that was used in conjunction with a functioning old fashioned box spring. That combination and setup allowed for better weight distribution and shock absorption. The flexibility of the box spring allows it to absorb some of the movements from the mattress, reducing wear and tear over time. With a futon, the additional set of springs that would normally work together with the functioning box spring, in not there.
At the end of the day, it really isn’t about whether the futon and legacy box spring will work, or work together, it is more about the type of comfort combination you are looking for.
Another option could be to use a platform with a layer of latex and/or a layer of microcoils between the futon and platform to add the needed cushion firm feel you are looking for.
Hope this helps, good luck with your project.
Maverick