Me: 5’9" - 126lbs (18.6 BMI)
Him: 6’3" - 190lbs (23.7 BMI)
We are in our 30s.
I am a very light sleeper and one of those people who cannot just fall asleep anywhere. I exclusively sleep on my side but have issues with the right side of my body, possibly stemming from a bad mattress, and have a lot of pain and numbness in my hip and leg when on that side. I have always preferred a somewhat softer mattress but I do not like feeling like I sink deep into the mattress, especially because I like to read and spend time on the computer in bed. I also have some lower back pain from my current mattress (cheapo foam) but it is hard to figure out what setup would be best for me since this mattress is absolutely terrible with significant indentations and a firmer, center hump. When I do rest on the mattress alone I try to go towards the center where the foam is less degraded and supportive and so that makes me wonder if I need more of a medium-feel mattress, rather than a soft one. I have used latex pillows all my life and love them, and so that, plus wanting a more natural bed, has me looking at an all-latex mattress.
I am not sure what configuration to get - even after months of research, I still feel uncertain. I don’t really have the option to test any mattresses in person so I must rely on what I read. Obviously not ideal. I thought maybe a soft talalay layer, medium talalay layer, firm dunlop layer might be the way to go but I am not sure. Will the middle medium layer in talalay feel supportive, yet soft enough? Or would it be better in dunlop?
I don’t really want to go much higher than 9" for the mattress height as my current mattress is only 8" and sort of ideal for my bedroom setup (nightstand height, bed frame height, etc). I also want to have some wiggle room in the event that I did end up needing a topper.
As for my husband, he is mostly a side sleeper but will occasionally fall asleep on his back. He has fewer issues with pressure points, but our current mattress is so sunken on his side that he has back pain and tosses and turns all night. He says he is not picky and just wants a new mattress, but I think he actually would prefer something more suited to him. I don’t know if we should get a mattress with split latex, or if it’s usually better to have it be a solid layer across the width of the mattress. I really don’t want to have a weird lump form in the middle, nor a crevice where the split is, but maybe a soft talalay layer would be too soft for him and break down quickly?
I’ve looked at so many different mattresses at this point, and have had numerous moments where I thought I had figured it out, but then find real reviews of terrible customer service experiences, or the wrong product was sent, or it takes months for the mattress to show up. Also, many of the mattresses that I liked the look of I think would be way too firm for me.
I think I have mostly settled on getting a SleepEZ Organic Latex Mattress in a Queen, for the company’s reputability, the option for both talalay and dunlop latex and a variety of firmnesses, and for the price. I just feel really uncertain about the layering configuration. I also am really trying to avoid testing out layers and having to do returns because I live in a walk-up apartment in NYC and don’t drive. Getting a heavy, bulky package to the post office seems like a hassle I don’t want to put myself through. Basically, I just need help with understanding how soft “soft” is, and maybe info on what a common setup for someone with our sleeping preferences and weights would be. Thanks!