I’ve been trying to find a comfortable new mattress over the past few months, without much success. I’ve bought and had to return two mattresses (“S Brand” innersprings) already and things aren’t looking good for #3 (a foam “bed-in-a-box”), so I’m exploring options for #4. It’s been really hard to find a bed that provides good alignment for me and is plush enough for comfort.
After perusing the forum here, I’m thinking a latex or latex-hybrid mattress might be right for me, so I’m going to try a few out this weekend at a local mattress store. However, I’m a little befuddled about how firm I should be going for.
I’m a side sleeper, 5’9" and about 225 lbs, with pretty broad shoulders and a thick build. (I’m hoping to lose a few pounds, but aren’t we all?)
I emailed Sleep On Latex to ask which of their Pure Green mattresses would be ideal, and they recommended the “Soft” model, which is 2" of soft dunlop over 6" of medium-soft dunlop. But I also tried the online “Mattress Configurator” on the Sleep EZ website, which suggested 2" of medium talalay, 3" of medium dunlop and 3" of firm dunlop – a much firmer build! To top it off, the Spindle website said I probably wouldn’t be comfortable on their mattress at all!
I know not every latex mattress is alike, but these seem like pretty disparate results. To make it even harder, my weight of 225 lbs is right on the edge of what most reviewers consider “heavy” – most say “over 230 lbs” is heavy, but others say “over 250”, “low 200s” or don’t give a weight at all.
So yeah, what should I do? As a broad-shouldered side sleeper, I need softness and contouring, but as a relatively heavy dude, I also need support.
What level of firmness should I be looking for in a latex mattress? Or should I avoid all-latex beds and look for a latex-over-springs hybrid for extra support?
Thanks,
Noah