Hi Drak,
Welcome to the Mattress UnderGround. We are happy to have you here.
Wow, you had the BeautyRest quite a long time, just as the industry was changing from the two sided mattress standard, to the “new” one sided approach. Consider yourself grateful that your BR endured that test of time, as you might not see that again from them in quite sometime. Not that it is entirely “their” fault but the modern prioritization of profit over the legacy of quality has hit some of the most beloved brands of yesteryear fairly hard. Corporate pressure certainly is alive and well.
Fortunately in your price range you will be surprised to find a lot of great options. And if you choose, many of our Trusted Members are experts in this area. If you have perused our tutorials you know we tend to take the “less is more approach” when it comes to mattress design and construction.
I must say, despite what is going on with the S brands these days, the Sealy Naturals mattress is impressive, even though it is 2-2.5x your price point.
You may want to consider @My_Green_Mattress in this category considering your price point. If hand tufting is not a priority, then @Sleep_EZ may provide you with an option and @Latex_Mattress_Fact1 may also have DIY option for you to consider to maintain your pricing structure. This is based on a king sized mattress, as you did not mention size, which is a key factor in pricing as there can often be a nice jump from a queen to a king. @Arizona_Premium is another manufacturer like the ones already mentioned that offer options that fit the profile of what you are looking for.
When searching for a new mattress always consider your 4R’s. Refund, Return, Restocking Fee and Reputation/Reviews (independent non website reviews, just to get previous mattress purchasers real time reviews) so you may understand what others have experienced from handling the “paperwork and process” perspective.
Creating a DIY mattress or collaborating with a manufacturer can give you control over materials, firmness levels, and customization options, ensuring you get exactly what you need for comfort and support.
Advantages of DIY or Custom Collaboration
- Tailored Comfort: You can adjust the firmness and support to match your specific needs.
- Durability: High-quality materials like natural latex and organic covers ensure longevity.
- Eco-Friendly: Using natural and organic materials reduces your environmental impact.
- Cost-Effective: Often, DIY or customizable options can be more affordable than pre-assembled high-end mattresses.
While there are other options out there, such as EcoSleep and Birch, that fit within your price range, these might sacrifice the customization and personal collaboration you want. By having more control over the final product, and with co-collaborators vested in achieving the best outcome, you can ensure the mattress meets your specific needs and preferences, making it a worthwhile investment for long-term comfort and satisfaction.
Remember you project does not stop with the mattress. As you mattress choices lean more firm, you pillow needs may change with it. Allow yourself some time to adjust to the new material of your mattress combination and choose the appropriate pillow accordingly.
You may want to peruse my pillow exploits and obsession for tips on how to choose and how to sleep on you pillow. Position on the pillow can make a difference for those who are more sensitive.
Finally, your foundation. A mattress is only as good as its weakest link. The foundation is part of you mattress system. A foundation like the soon to be released Kinckerbocker Em Brace 360 Platform is one that will be a performance superstar when it gets released in the next few weeks.
I was so impressed with this foundation and its ability to support virtually any weight mattress while effectively controlling motion isolation. I plan to order it for my current mattress, as it will seamlessly integrate with my existing headboard, footboard, and sideboard setup, preserving the cosmetic appearance. Additionally, I won’t have to worry about looking under my bed to check for proper mattress support. This foundation was perhaps the most impressive component I encountered at the mattress and home furnishings show here in Las Vegas.
I know this was a bit long winded, but all with the best intentions as I hope it helps.
Maverick