Hello everyone,
I am about to purchase a mattress after having made the mistake of buying a Serta Perfect Sleeper on a whim (I am fortunately still within the 7 day return period)–I am usually one to meticulously research things before I purchase them, but I guess I was feeling impulsive that day.
Regardless, I have read the information on this website and am trying to make the best decision I can. Most of the furniture stores in Oklahoma City are owned by the same local family, so any semblance of competition or choice is more or less illusory. Nonetheless, one local store offers Lady Americana mattresses (made locally) and another offers mattresses made by Sleep, Inc. (manufacturer or Englander, Spring Air, & Therapedic) to their specifications (also made locally). As far as I can tell, those are my best two options in town, but I am seeking the wisdom on these forums before I pull the trigger.
My max is around $1,000 for a queen-sized mattress–I don’t need box springs since I have a platform bed. I have narrowed my options down to two possibilities and would like your feedback on them, as well as any additional suggestions I should add to my list.
Option 1: Lady Americana “Magnifico” Box-Top (Silver Line) - $880
Height: 15"
Quilt/Cover: Four-way Stretch w/Silk plus High loft Fiber and 1.5" Supersoft foam
Comfort Layer: 3.75" Supersoft Foam - 1" Poly - .5" Talalay Lumbar Support
Mattress Support: 704 Individually Encased Coil Unit
Option 2: Sleep Spa Wellness Series “Refuge Plush” (made by Sleep Inc.) - $750
Height: 12"
Quilt: A non-toxic fire-retardant barrier quilted with 2 layers of Supersoft Luxury Foam
Upholstery: Talalay latex inlay with full panel layer of HD Luxury Foam
Coil Unit: 768 foam encased 3-zoned wrapped coils that have higher gauge steel in center third for more support
Edge support: Ultra foam encasement for added support and edge firmness
I tried to get more specific information about both models, but to no avail. I couldn’t even get information about the thicknesses of the layers on the “Refuge” model, and neither store had any idea about densities. I asked for spec sheets and they looked at me like I was nuts.
Regardless, given what little information I have given you and whatever knowledge you might have about these two manufacturers, what recommendations can you make for me? I am leaning toward the Refuge because its comfort layer doesn’t seem nearly as thick as the box top on the Lady Americana. The box top is quite comfy but I worry that it might break down quickly. Plus, I figure I can always add a latex topper to the Refuge if I want/need a thicker comfort layer.
Thanks in advance for your help!