Mattress shopping is hard. 😟

Mattress Talk Needs & Personal Preferences
, , , , ,
1

Here’s my crazy list of criteria:

  1. I’m 5’9", 165lbs, 57 years old and live in northern Virginia.
  2. I like beds that are soft but with firm support that I’m not aware I’m getting if that’s somehow possible. I have dealt with lots of back issues both muscular and pinched nerves in both neck and lower back. No surgeries and currently doing well. But back pain is generally part of my life.
  3. 70% side sleeper with knees bent, 30% back, 0% stomach.
  4. I know I want coils. I am pretty sure I want latex upper (hybrid I guess is the fancy name for it nowadays) but overall medium firmness – again what I really want is soft but firm if that’s somehow possible. I am not opposed to a layer or foam in there also if there is value in doing so but I do not want memory foam on top, that’s for sure. I roll over every couple of hours when I sleep and when I’m on memory foam, I wake up unable to roll with the feeling of being in quick sand. No thanks.
  5. Production mattresses make me nervous about material and build quality. I’ve seen enough of Spencer at Ventura tearing up name brand mattresses and finding dumpster fires inside.
  6. As such, I would REALLY prefer to find a local mattress builder where I’m buying from the facility where it was made. But alas no such luck here on the east coast that I can find, except…
  7. Original Mattress Factory. I’ve been brand loyal to them for 30 years and have loved both mattresses I’ve bought there. The only reason I don’t want to go with them this time is that I want a mattress that I can put on an adjustable frame at some point in the near future, and their traditional coils are a non-starter for that.
  8. I want a mattress that will work well on an adjustable frame.
  9. If I can’t find a local builder, then I want a mattress with a zippered cover so that I can (A) inspect the guts, and more importantly (B) change out a top layer (or possibly 2) rather than return an entire mattress, if/when I want a change.
  10. I’m not necessarily opposed to bed-in-a-box although something about it still makes me kind of squint when I’m watching the thousand of video reviews. I just get the sense that (A) I’m paying $500-$700 for marketing and customer acquisition if I go that route – it’s clear they are at war for eyes and consumers and paying lots in the arms race, and I know who’s paying for those arms – me. And (B) I just can’t help but wonder if these beds-in-boxes are really legitimately 10-15 year mattresses. If I’m wrong please tell me.

Help a brother out!

One simple question is, where can I go to feel the difference between Talalay and Dunlap as a top layer? I tried Mattress Firm and Mattress Warehouse which both have several production brands, but the pretty picture guides of ingredients don’t mention that detail – just “latex” or some fancy derivation thereof. And the staff is ignorant.

But the broader question is, please recommend a mattress and/or place to buy one.

1 Like
2

Hey InternetToughGuy.

You’re not wrong. Mattress shopping IS hard and a lot of folks end up with analysis paralysis. It’s part of why we wrote our Mattress Shopping Tutorial.

You can pair an adjustable base with both all-foam and all-latex mattresses. An innerspring mattress can also work on an adjustable base, but only if it has a wrapped coil system. Bonnell or Verticoil coil systems aren’t compatible with adjustable bases.

If the components are durable, they really are going to have the lifespan you expect of them. But so many aren’t using quality components.

We’ll always start by pointing you to our Trusted Members but for your needs in particular, I’d say start with Arizona Premium which will allow you to do a sort of DIY that meets your exact specs.

Others I’d say to start with would be Engineered Sleep and Latex Mattress Factory. Because you’re not nearby these stores and can’t walk in, I’d definitely recommend giving them a call to explain exactly what you’re looking for so they can help match you with the best fit from their inventory.

Let us know what questions or issues arise. We’re standing by!

NikkiTMU

1 Like
3

I just wanted to chime in here as @NikkiTMU did an excellent job of responding to your general inquiry.

People sometimes look at the Bed in the Box industry as some type of sub par way to purchase a mattress. Often with the mindset not unlike your perception of marketing and advertising occupying much of the cost of the purchase price of a mattress.

I would have to admit some of my favorite mattress brands on the planet are not bed in a box, brands like Shifman, Millbrook, ViSpring, Custom Comfort and a few others that stick out in my mind at the moment. Although, I currently sleep on a Bed in a Box mattress, and my wife and I simply love it, even after 2 years in. And two of our guest room mattresses are BinB’s.

Having said that, brands like what @TheCleanBedroom sell, such as Naturepedic, or @DLX mattress, @EngineeredSleep, along with the latex experts here at TMU @Arizona_Premium, @Sleep_EZ, @FloBeds, @CST and a few others sell, are all bed in a box that not only rival the S and legacy brands out there, quite frankly they exceed them in quality. engineering and build.

Much like the Auto industry in the 1970’s where the big 3 legacy auto manufacturers saw a huge dip in quality, setting the stage for the Japanese brands like Toyota and Datsun to enter the market, and now one might suggest dominate the market, Something similar with the Legacy mattress brands compared to the American Made Bed in the Box that are creating the same buzz over recent years.

For what it is worth, I appreciate your perspective! It’s true that marketing plays a significant role in the mattress industry, but it’s important to note that as I previously mentioned, many legacy brands, including some well-known “S” brands and Tempurpedic, allocate much more of their budget to marketing and advertising than most American-made bed-in-a-box companies. This means that when you buy those legacy brands, a larger portion of your payment goes toward their advertising efforts rather than the actual product.

As for the longevity of bed-in-a-box mattresses, many reputable brands offer high-quality materials and warranties that support their lifespan of 10-15 years. It’s always a good idea to look for transparent independent off website reviews and verified customer feedback to help inform your decision.

At the end of a long day, as Nikki mentioned, the key factors for longevity are the quality of materials and components, along with choosing the right mattress for your body type and preferences. Many mattress failures stem from poor selection and insufficient research, not due to the decision to selection between bed in the box or traditional.

Just a thought!

Maverick

2 Likes
4

Hi there,
Thanks to Maverick for the mention!
There’s a Savvy Rest showroom in Vienna VA - I bet you could feel the difference between Talalay and Dunlop there. I believe they have both. If you aren’t close to Vienna, I’m sure they have other showrooms in VA as their home base is Charlottesville VA.
As you might expect, all beds in a box are not made equal. Some may make their beds ahead and hold them in stock. Naturepedic does not do that - they make each bed to order and the quality of materials and craftmanship is excellent. The coils are pocketed individually, so most models can be used on an adjustable bed. Most of their mattresses are customizable, so you can swap out one of the components if it isn’t working for you. And if you need a change years down the road, you can just buy one of the components instead of a whole new mattress.25-year warranty.
There’s a Naturepedic showroom in the DC area. If you’d like to talk to one of our staff, we are happy to help you by phone also.
Hope this helps!

2 Likes
5

So basically, I should check out the sponsors of this forum. Roger that. There is simply no escape from marketing wormholes in the search for real mattress information. It is fascinating.

6

Hi @InternetToughGuy - I was tagged and love helping - so I wanted to let you know what we have to offer that meets your needs. I know you are tired of the marketing (it is a crazy marketing world in all industries) - so I will try to be straightforward.

Our Duo Latex Mattress hits a few key points you mentioned.

  1. We are an East Coast manufacturer and we just have 1 location where we make and sell all of our mattresses. We are in Greenville, SC and have been since 1931.
  2. This mattress allows you to replace the Comfort Layers only over time (not a zipper cover for quality purposes, but we can give you every single spec).
  3. The Duo Latex Plus option offers soft comfort, but firm support (we use a Texas Pocket Spring QuadCoil that is very supportive and will last a long time). We use Dunlop in the standard options, but we can switch to Talalay if it makes sense or is desired.
  4. It works with an adjustable bed frame.

Feel free to search Reddit - tons of organic conversations from people who have our mattresses (not marketing or solicited in anyway). We also have some good videos on our YouTube page explaining the Duo Mattress with some visuals.

Good luck in your search!

2 Likes