I recently purchased a new gel foam mattress, but unfortunately, it’s too hard for me. Initially it seemed OK. I felt fine when I’d go to bed, but after a while, it felt like it got harder the longer I’d lay on it. As a result, I toss and turn throughout the night, only to wake up stiff sore and tired.
I got it from Amazon.com, and when I called them to exchange it, they simply refunded my money and said to keep it. I guess it would cost them more for the return shipping than it’s worth. So now I need to decide if I should get different mattress or just add a topper to the one I have. And if so, which brand, model, etc.? I’m leaning toward a topper because it’s obviously cheaper, easier to handle, and I wouldn’t have the hassle getting rid of another mattress; but will they do the trick and do they last long?
I’m a 50 year old male who weighs 230 lbs. My budget is $265. The mattress is on a platform bed frame. I’m a side sleeper, but move throughout the night, and sometimes end up on my back or even my stomach.
The mattress I have now is a queen sizeClassic Brands, Cool Gel, 8 inch foam mattress. (It’s also sold under the brand name Sleep Trends, through Macy’s, PostureLoft through Overstock.com, and ModernSleep through Walmart.)
I chose it based on my experience at a local retailer who sold the same mattress under their store name. Being that I move a lot throughout the night, I liked that it offered some plush contouring, [though it could use some more] while still being easy to move on. I definitely don’t like typical memory form mattresses, due to the “crater” feeling I get, making it difficult to move or the heat issues. Classic Brands does make a 10.5" Cool Gel version, that’s only $40 more, but I’m not certain if the hardness is due to the material or thickness. Both are referred to as “medium” by Classic Brands. I am willing to compromise a little on the movement if a more comfortable mattress means less tossing and turning.
Here are two gel foam toppers I’m considering: Cloud9 Gel Foam 2" Topper and Milard 2" Gel Foam Topper. I chose them because most other seem to rip too easily, and based on the reviews, these stay relatively cool and don’t restrict movement too much. Both are 2", because I was thinking thinner means less “sinking in a hole” or would still be hard? Would a 3 inch gel-foam topper add more comfort without restricting movement? I have tested regular memory foam toppers and the thicker ones do sink a little too much for my liking.
I’m open to all suggestions so please feel free to share your thoughts.
Thanks in advance for all your input.
doc_v2018