Hi lab3,
I can only speak to the quality and value of a mattress and perhaps provide a caution for any weak links or possible risks I see. In the case of Brooklyn Bedding … like all of the members here … their mattresses are among the best quality and value in the country and in the right circumstances any of them would make good choices.
The suitability of a mattress though is something else completely and as you can see in an earlier reply today in post #2 here … either personal testing on similar mattresses or the ideas and insights of a manufacturer that can use the “averages” of their customers that may be similar to you to help you decide which of their mattresses may work well for different types of people are the best way to make specific mattress choices.
In this case (and in others that they will also introduce over time) … you have a “model” that you can test locally which will give you a good approximation of how the mattress will feel and perform for your specific circumstances and this along with more detailed conversations with them is the “best” way to choose which one is most suitable for you and which one is the best match for your “personal value equation”.
Phoenix
PS: I deleted your other thread which was a duplicate of this one.