After lurking on these forums for awhile, my wife and I finally overcame our indecision and purchased a SF Regalis mattress. We loved the TP Rhapsody at the local mattress discounters but couldn’t justify the cost. We weren’t as fond of the 5.3 lb/ft^3 TPs, and we definitely weren’t impressed with the iComforts, Sealy PPs, or any of the hybrids.
Because the Rhapsody was so expensive—and we didn’t particularly like any of the name brand competitors—we briefly considered Sam’s Club and Costco. The Sam’s Club brands, in particular Night Therapy, seemed to be low end, with densities topping out at 3 lb/ft^3. I found a few Sleep Science models from Costco with 5 lb/ft^3 foam in the $1500 range, but I wasn’t ready to commit to that knowing our (limited) experience with the 5 lb/ft^3 TP.
After doing some research, I realized that what we really wanted was the high density memory foam (> 7 lb/ft^3), so I narrowed in on that. I came across the Regalis at selectfoam.com and noticed that the layer stack was almost identical to the Rhapsody, so I was intrigued. After reading many reviews (actually all of them) posted on trustlink, I was a bit skeptical of the company, but they seem to be respected around here.
I called and placed my order with Peter today and received the MUG discount. From trustlink, I know there have been issues with returns in the past; it looks like the company has recently changed their policy so that they will pay for return shipping. This made me feel a lot better about the decision, as I’m still feeling a bit nervous about buying a mattress I’ve never seen.
This site was a tremendous resource and very helpful to the decision making process. The world of mattress (marketing) seems, frankly, very scammy, but this site helped us find our way through all the BS. Thanks to all of you who have contributed your stories. I’ll update this post in the future with our thoughts on the Regalis.
TL;DR. Fell in love with $3500 Rhapsody mattress. Bought a Regalis from Select Foam. They now offer free return shipping. Thanks for the amazing resource!