Yo!
I was encouraged to check out The Mattress Underground on a Discord channel that’s dedicated to a specific brand of clothing, and phew, I’m so glad to be here! I spent the last couple of hours reading through the comprehensive/complete tutorial and its-over-a-dozen hyperlinks to try and educate myself a bit before making this post. Neither I nor my partner know anything about mattresses. I’ve learned more this afternoon than most will in a lifetime!
For the past coming-up-on 8 years, my partner (female, ~120#) and I (male, ~170#) have been sleeping on a queen-sized mattress she had purchased from Casper back in 2016—we think it’s this version, which, if I did my homework correctly, is considered a “progressive construction,” is that right? After about a year of use, we purchased and kept it enclosed in a hypoallergenic cover until November 2022 when, while removing it to wash as we do seasonally, I noticed the material on the inside had flaked ALL over our mattress—top, bottom, and sides. After painstakingly spending well over an hour vacuuming every flaked bit in sight, we switched to using a simple top cover like this. Aside from that cover (which we wash seasonally, but probably should more often), we have one fitted sheet (washed weekly or sometimes biweekly) that we sleep on top of. Oh, and the mattress sits atop a Thuma bed frame, which we like very much.
More context: our apartment in Brooklyn tends to get really humid. If it weren’t for our dehumidifier, we’d be living in the 60-70% range, and even higher during spring/summer. But we try to run our dehumidifier enough to keep things between 50-55% as consistently as we can. I recently noticed quite a bit of funk emanating from our mattress; I realized it very suddenly, as if the smell developed overnight, but in reality I know it’s years of humidity, sweat, and our dead skin working concertedly to put a look on my face like I smelled some piss. (No, we’re not bedwetters! ) My partner is also highly sensitive and in some cases allergic to fine particulates (dust, allergens, etc.). Lately, her nose has been getting clogged and her skin flaring up more often. I’m thinking our mattress may be the culprit, considering I vacuum 1-2x a week, dust once a week, and we sleep with an air purifier running every night. Finally, in terms of personal preferences, we both like “less soft” upper layers and “firmer” deeper layers. Where we differ is in our body temperatures and sleeping positions (kind of). I run hot, and she runs cold. We both sleep on our backs, but sometimes shift to our sides while sleeping. Generally, we both fall asleep and wake up on our backs, and less frequently on our sides (she wakes up on her side a little more than I do).
My partner put me in charge of research—hence this post—but I’m a little bewildered by all the options. All or mostly latex sounds great, especially considering our humid environment and my partner’s allergies. But damn they’re expensive! An innerspring/latex hybrid sounds like a nice compromise. She sent me a few links to mattresses she found through our uninspired millennial tactics:
- Birch Natural Mattress
- Saatva Classic Mattress
- The Aviya Mattress
- Naturepedic Concerto Organic Hybrid Mattress
I just don’t know where to go from here and am looking for some more direction, suggestions, and specific mattress recommendations! Our range is anywhere between $700 to $1500 (willing to go a little higher).
Please feel free to ask me specific questions, too. I’ll be happy to answer them!