Im 5’11" 220lbs, fall asleep on my side but toss and turn all night because of hip and shoulder pain. Cannot fall asleep on my back. I sleep alone. Researching for weeks, but dont know if half the stuff i’m reading is true.
Would like to get some recommendations for mattresses.
1 Like
Hi Blongtrance,
Welcome to the mattress underground and thanks for your question. I’m 6’ and around 220 myself. I tend to prefer a firmer mattress, usually fall asleep on my back, then rotate to my side through the night and occasionally wake up on my stomach.
Mattress comfort is extremely subjective, so it helps to know what has and has not worked for you in the past. A lot of people automatically blame the mattress, but hip and shoulder pain can also come from an old or weak foundation, slats with too much flex, or a support system that is no longer holding proper alignment. Sometimes the foundation is fine and the comfort layers are the issue.
At your height and weight, you are generally considered a plus-sized sleeper, so durability and support become more important. You will likely want to focus on mattresses built with higher density foams, stronger coil systems, or latex comfort layers that will maintain alignment longer term.
There are several mattresses built specifically for larger sleepers, such as the Helix Plus Elite, Titan Plus series, and others that use more robust support systems with different comfort configurations. Companies like BackScience also take a more ergonomic approach with features like their lumbar flex system that can increase support through the midsection while allowing more pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.
You also have good options with some of the natural and component-style mattress companies like Organic Bedroom, Plank and Coil, My Green Mattress, SleepEZ, and Arizona Premium. Some of these companies can help customize the feel and layering based on your body type and sleeping position, while others build mattresses with targeted comfort zones to better accommodate side sleepers who deal with hip and shoulder pressure.
There probably is not one perfect mattress for everyone in your situation, but there are definitely mattresses that are better suited for your build and sleeping style. Based on what you described, I would probably lean toward a supportive hybrid with either latex or a high quality pressure relieving comfort layer rather than an ultra firm traditional mattress. Side sleepers at your weight usually need enough surface comfort to relieve pressure while still keeping the spine aligned.
Some folks prefer zoned comfort that targets specific areas of the body, others prefer a single zoned surface area with comfort layers that contour and and compliment the support of a more robust support layer.
You may also want to consider some of the natural mattress options that use materials like latex, wool, cotton, alpaca, horsehair and other natural fibers. These materials tend to sleep more temperature neutral than many synthetic foams and can help create a cooler, drier and more comfortable sleeping environment throughout the night.
I can tell you from personal experience, we currently have five mattresses in our home, all with very different feels and designs. We sleep on a Brooklyn Bedding Plank Luxe, which is a very firm mattress, and we love it. In our guest rooms, we have a Brooklyn Bedding ThermoBalance Elite Firm and a Titan Plus Elite. Neither is as firm as the Plank, but both are extremely comfortable because the surface comfort layers provide enough contouring and secondary support to relieve pressure around the hips and shoulders while still maintaining good alignment.
The GlacierSleep Apex is another example, with a softer medium feel on top, but a support system robust enough to engage underneath the softer comfort layers so your body does not sink too deeply. That combination of pressure relief and underlying support is what many side sleepers your size are really trying to find.
Just remember, I can not stress the use of a quality, robust, foundation in all of this, along with the selection of a good pillow for side sleeping. I like the OxygenPillow from European Sleep Works.
Hope this helps.
Maverick