Thanks Sensei.
We actually think we’re going to go with a solid birch wood slatted made in Canada bed from MFC. It’ll be in the $1000 CAD range and will support any mattress we buy.
We started our mattress journey today, and it sure will be challenging with a 1.5 year old in tow.
I am a back and stomach sleeper. I try my side most nights, as it lets me be closer to my wife, but I often find myself turning back onto my back not long after. And then I flip between back and stomach throughout the night.
My wife is predominantly a side sleeper, which she got into while pregnant. She sometimes finds herself on her back as that was her previous predominant position, and it’s what has previously been recommended by medical professionals because of an s curve in her spine.
Me - 6’, 190lb, stomach/back
Wife - 5’3", 120lb, side/back
We visited Matelas Dauphin first. We tried several talalay latex, memory foam, hybrid (pocket coil + latex or pocket coil + memory foam) and pocket coil mattresses.
I favoured the London, which is their pocket coil support with foam comfort: Matelas London - Matelas Dauphin
We were told:
- 2" viscos gel (Gel-Flex), 3 lb, 10 ILD comfort layer
- 4" pocket coils. 14 gauge in the middle zone, 15 gauge in the upper and lower zones
- 4" support layer of 2 lb polyfoam at 33 ILD
I found that the 2" of foam really cradled my back, and didn’t interfere in stomach sleeping. The pocket coil transition to the firmer 4" foam base was excellent. My wife found this bed too firm for her. It didn’t provide enough pressure point relief in the comfort layer.
My concern here is the durability of the 3 lb comfort layer.
My wife favoured a medium firm Hotel Collection pocket coil: Hotel Collection Mattress | Matelas Dauphin
I couldn’t get her to provide me a copy of the spec sheet, but we were told that all foam layers were 2.5 lb polyfoam. I don’t have the thickness or gauge of the coils or the thickness of the foam, but again the coils had a softer middle zone. I suspect guages were the same as the London.
We also tried one of their semi-firm pocket coil mattresses. I believe it was the Sapphire 2 or 3. My wife found it too firm for her, but I preferred it over Hotel Collection.
I regret not having tried something firmer for myself or softer for my wife, just to get a comparison. She has wide hips and is pretty light; I think she’d benefit from something softer, while I certainly favoured something a bit firmer.
This store has a 50% off end of year sale ending tomorrow. I know one shouldn’t fall into the sense of urgency of a sale, but for a mere $50 deposit they will actually honour the sale price for a full year. We are extremely tempted to buy into the marketing scheme as the mattresses are of a great quality, and if we find something we prefer elsewhere (a) $50 isn’t much money; and (b) we need a guest bed too.
They also have a 120 day trial period with in-store credit, and they’d honour the 50% off for a change. It’s a $50 delivery fee to change out the mattress once.
Sale price, the London was $1250 and the Hotel was $1050.
Some takeaways:
- Neither of us liked the feel of Talalay latex
- My wife favoured pocket coils with a more plush/softer conventional foam comfort layer for her side sleeping
- I favoured pocket coils with a firmer memory foam comfort layer (“hybrid”) for my back and stomach sleeping
- We certainly want to try some more pocket coil options, with both memory foam and polyfoam comfort layers. I think we’d also benefit from trying something firmer for her and softer for me to understand the recommended middle-firm compromise
Next up was Obasan. We spent a couple of hours here and tied a lot of different Dunlop latex mattresses. From customising left and right to fully customising 6 zones, we tried several different combinations.
I’ll continue my account later, when I have more time to write it.