Advice on best mattress for plus size mom

Talk To The Experts
1

Hi!
Summary- I am looking for a new mattress, surprise surprise. I am 200 lbs, 5’3, side sleeper, 36 years old and have had 2 babies in the last 2 years. Both usually end up sleeping with me. Husband is in separate bed. I already have a latex topper I’d love to keep using.

I have always loved soft, plush beds but probably need something medium or firm due to my weight, though unsure how that will work with side sleeping? A few years ago I got a very expensive plush split king tempurpedic that is basically a torture device now. My husband still enjoys his firm side! I moved to the guest bed to be more comfortable and to let the toddler sleep with me without bothering dad. The guest bed needs to be replaced- it’s old and very uneven from years of use in the past. I typically wake up with sore hips. I purchased a 2 in medium-firm latex topper from SleepOnLatex to help in the meantime. I’m unsure if I’m better off with pure latex mattress (I’ve always loved the bouncy feel in my pillows) or hybrid with coils? I am not a fan of memory foam because of my experience but also not super safe with little ones in the bed. What would be best to support my needs? Currently looking at budget friendly options, like the Roma mattress based on my searches through this forum. Edge support is also
Important to me because of the little ones- any thoughts on the Awara Natural Luxury Hybrid Mattress

Thank you! This community is amazing!

1 Like
2

Hi Serialchiller,

Welcome to Mattress Underground! As a plus-sized side sleeper, your mattress really needs a strong, supportive base and the foundation you place it on is just as important as the mattress itself, so it is worth considering before making a final choice.

If I were to guess, your Tempur-Pedic is letting you sink too much, which can feel like sleeping in hot lava quicksand and may be causing your hip soreness. While your 2-inch latex topper from SleepOnLatex can help in the short term, it will ultimately reflect the characteristics of the mattress underneath, so if the base mattress is sagging, your topper will catch up and you will still feel it. An all-latex mattress can provide the some of the bounce and responsiveness you enjoy from pillows, and it is durable and generally safe for co-sleeping toddlers, but pillows are not made with the same load capacity as mattress support components. This will also effect they way you feel on the mattress which will feel a bit different than your body resting on the entire mattress. A hybrid mattress with latex and coils can offer more lift and support, making it less likely to sag under your weight while still giving bounce and comfort for side sleeping, and hybrids often provide better edge support which is important with little ones in bed.

Budget-friendly options such as the Roma mattress or the Awara Natural Luxury Hybrid could work well, with the Awara suggesting its edge support and supportive hybrid construction.

On that subject, not a big Awara fan as they have been mostly made overseas, and Resident Brands has a history of using lower quality more budget targeted foams and materials in the construction of their mattresses. They are more of a marketing company rather than a mattress company, despite being bought by Ashley Furniture.

In the mainstream of quality DTC, BiB mattresses, The Titan Series, Helix Plus, Leesa Plus and Nolah Comfort Plus are some that have excellent spring support layers, with nice competent edge support. Mattresses like DLX’s classic hybrid or Engineered Sleep Classic, offer great options for plus sized sleepers. Any of these can be used together with your latex topper.

There are always going to be some mattress somewhere, perhaps several mattresses that will check all of your comfort boxes, the difficulty is narrowing them down and finding one that falls within your budget.

Most of what I have mentioned is in the under $1500 range in a King, from companies that offer quality mattresses along with quality customer service.

This is a quick brief overview of what is out there, but trust me there are dozens more. As I mentioned, there is always going to be more than one mattress that will check all the boxes, you just dont want to get too caught up with the marketing hype.

Hope this helps start your search journey.

Maverick

3

Based on your info our budget friendly Eco Sleep hybrid model sounds like a good fit and will have firmer edges than a full latex option and also a bit more bounce factor. I would choose the Medium option for the latex topper based on your size and weight. You can also use the latex topper you already have if you think it’s needed. Check it out at Eco Sleep Hybrid Latex / Coil Mattress, Latex Mattresses-Talalay and Dunlop, All Products, and let me know if you have any questions about it.

1 Like
4

Thank you so much for your response! I appreciate your time and info :slight_smile: good to know about Awara and the wide range of plus size mattresses available. Do you think my frame needs a plus specific one like the ones you mentioned or might I be ok on a “normal” latex or latex hybrid like the APM eco hybrid? Thanks again!!

1 Like
5

Thank you so much for your response! This mattress might just be perfect for me! I have wood slats as my base but not sure how many inches apart. It’s 10 inches high right?

What’s the best way to decide between hybrid and full latex? I’m definitely leaning toward latex hybrid based on both of the responses here, and more specifically the model you mentioned. I know you said it would be fine to use my topper if needed, but I was wondering if you could describe how it changes the overall feel or impact of the mattress features?

Thanks again!

6

You definitely do not have to sacrifice a plush top layer if that’s what you like. As long as you’ve got your strong support underneath, the plush top will not negate that. The problems come when both your topper and support are too soft.

2 Likes