Hi megan,
They wouldn’t be making the mattress you remember any longer and not only may your needs and preferences have changed but Stearns and Foster don’t make the same quality of mattresses as they did that long ago. They are one of the “major brands” I would avoid (see the mattress shopping guidelines here which is one of the links in the tutorial post here).
I’m glad you found us and that you are taking the time to do some good research and testing. I’m looking forward to finding out what you end up deciding … and of course any questions or feedback you may have along the way.
Phoenix