ISO new mattress after a too firm one for 10 years, hoping to get it right for the next 10

New here, and glad to have found this forum!

My husband and I are in the market for a new mattress. We have a 10 year old sagging, always been too firm for me cal king Therapedic backsense rhapsody that we paid close to 2K for a decade ago. I had a cal king memory foam topper that was too soft for my husband and I folded in half on my side of the bed until I got rid of it a little over a year ago since I felt like I was sinking in too much and my shoulders were rounding and I was having more neck pain. Slept fine without it for a few months, and right after I finally discarded the topper I started waking with numb heels while on my back, and sore hips and shoulders on my side. Been alternating on and off with a cheap walmart topper since, and its too soft with that and too firm without, and there is sagging in the mattress itself. All that to say, it is time, but also my experience with this one makes me want to really get it right this time. My husband prefers firm, which is why we got a firm mattress. He also sleeps very hot, so we are hoping to get something that he won’t end up waking drenched in sweat. I sleep colder and in the winter bring a heated bean bag thing in bed to keep my toes warm.

Given all of that, we are looking at hybrid latex mattresses, and we tried the Avocado green as it was the only one we could find in a nearby store. We were both pretty happy with the medium, but seems very expensive to me, and I worry that the top layer will wear out first and then you’re out a $3500 mattress in a few years. This one needs to last us 10 at minimum if we are spending that much. The sales rep told me that buying the firm avocado mattress and adding my own topper isn’t going to end up giving the same feel, as the layers in the main mattress are also different, not just the topper. From their website though that doesn’t seem to be the case. We do own two twin mattresses from MyGreenMattress and find those comfortable though we haven’t slept a night in them. I did notice some signs of wear on my 5.5 year old’s mattress already though, so that’s a bit concerning. Granted he sleeps like a log no matter what.

After looking at the avocado, as well as sales people showing me all the options and robot beds that sing you lullabies, I’ve gone down the rabbit hole looking at various other options of either a more affordable but comparable option to the Avocado, or I’m liking the option of getting the bed and the topper separately, especially if the topper wears out first. The sales rep also told me that the springs wear out first, but I’m not sold on that.

As far as heat, it looks like many toppers are just the latex with a cotton cover, but the hybrid mattresses with attached topper tend to have wool in the top layers to keep things cool. SleepEZ appears to have a topper with wool, or I’m curious about @EngineeredSleep 's version that is made to be adjustable with the bed and topper separate. We are in the Central Valley, CA, so @EuropeanSleep isn’t too far, and that option intrigues me as well, or there are so many others I’ve looked at in the past few days. The ability to easily return or exchange is also high on the list, especially if we can’t see it in person first. Open to any recs or advice! Also advice as to whether medium is the right choice given out heights and weights and sleep positions.

For the tl:dr, looking for hybrid cal king mattress solution for my husband and me. We don’t love the feel of memory foams, and like the idea of more natural materials, and the durability and temperature regulating properties of latex sound enticing.
Me: 5’10" 135lb mostly back sleeper, but also side, currently back because bed is too firm for side. History of herniated disc in low back, and head/neck pain/migraines.

My husband: 6’4" about 210lbs, mostly side sleeper but sleeps in any position, snores with allergies, and sleeps hot.

Thanks in advance just for reading if you got this far!

5 Likes

HI, I’m sure others will weigh in here but have you looked at the Back Science Mattresses? We had similar issues and have a BS2 and love it! Everyone is different and there are lots of good options out there, but I thought I would mention this brand as one to look at.

Happy Hunting!

2 Likes

There’s a lot of stuff to go over to make sure you are maximizing the performance of a new mattress, especially with a latex hybrid where you are also paying a premium for cotton fabrics and wool fills. The foundation matters quite a bit as well, so a little investigation into slat strength, center support, etc…, is super important (basically, you’d rather have a good foundation with a mediocre mattress than the other way around). For hot sleepers, and people who are concerned about contact pressure, the protective covers (mattress pads) are super important also. Unfortunately, the advocacy of waterproof, allergy, bed bug, cooling, etc…, has led to sweaty, uncomfortable mattresses that don’t breathe or contour correctly. I actually prefer the feel of a topper, but that’s subjective, and it varies for everyone. Also, here’s a weird one–higher performance mattresses that reduce pressure, isolate motion, transport moisture, and support correctly will wear out a little faster (even with more durable parts), as they are ā€œworkingā€ harder (modern tempered springs or coils don’t wear out btw, it’s the softer more flexible materials). This makes repairability (and a good durable construction with proper support) super important. I realize that this was a lot, but that’s what we are here for, right? Call us anytime if you want to chat about options. Cheers :slight_smile:

1 Like

Thanks for the tips so far, still doing research and finally mapping out options on paper. I did online chat yesterday with sleepEZ and Avocado. For anyone else wondering, sounds like the sales rep I talked to in a store about Avocado had no idea what he was talking about. Someone from the actual site confirmed that the mattresses for the green are all the same, just the top layers vary for comfort levels, so adding a topper to the basic green mattress would give a very similar feel to the medium version, and they said that’s a great way to add longevity. Also verified that the claim that guy in the store made about the springs wearing out before the topper was basically garbage. As also verified in other thread on this site. Just throwing that out there in case it saves anyone else time. Heavily leaning towards a mattress with detached topper, and looking for the topper to include wool in the cover or inside for heat dissipation.

Also, while looking at mattresses in stores, many advertised how they are hand sewn or attached through all the layers from top to bottom so that shifting is not an issue. I kind of like the idea of a mattress with interchangeable layers that you can adjust as needed, but I wonder what the deal is with shifting. With latex and coils, is that not so much of an issue? Basically, what are the pros and cons of all the layers being attached top to bottom versus a bunch of separated moveable layers in a zippered cover.

1 Like

Agree with Slumpy!!!

I have a BackScience 2!!! Love it!!!

John

1 Like

Hi @Lannalab - sorry I am late to the part here! You provided a lot of great info and I am sure there are a lot of great options out there for you.

Speaking to our products. Our Duo Latex Mattress does seem like a great fit and it does give you some flexibility in feel without be stuck. Based on the info you provided I would choose our ā€œCushion-Firmā€ Duo Latex option and you would most likely prefer the Duo Support flipped to the slightly softer side. The Duo Comfort Top uses Organic Cotton, Talalay Latex and New Zealand Wool (new addition in 2026).

BUT if that ended up being too firm we allow a Comfort Exchange during your 100 Night Trial and you could upgrade to the Latex Plus which provides more cushion, if needed. Even if both options, plus being able to flip the support, do not work - you can return the mattress for a full refund.

Feel free to chat in to our team or message me with any other questions.

Good luck!

2 Likes

Thanks for the input! I think I’ve narrowed down to definitely wanting a separate mattress and topper, and then trying to find combos and topper options that still have wool for cooling in the top layer. It’s looking like SleepEZ hybrid will be the most cost effective for my constraints and also allow for the most customizability down the line. I was also wondering about a mattress protector, as we have always used one and given that my husband runs warm, I’d like something I can wash if it gets sweaty, and something that doesn’t negate the temperature regulating effects of the wool underneath. Or mess with the comfort by restricting the latex movement or something. From SleepEZ with their hybrid mattress, I’m thinking my options are:

  1. Talalay topper +wool/cotton mattress protector
  2. Dunlop topper +wool/cotton mattress protector
  3. Wool latex topper + wool/cotton mattress protector

I would need some guidance deciding which thickness and type of latex for the toppers.

Given that I like more cushion, don’t like feeling like I’m ā€œfloatingā€ on the mattress, and my husband prefers more firm, and our heights/weights/sleep preferences listed in my first post, plus trying to ensure my husband doesn’t overheat and I don’t freeze, do those options sound wise? Is there another topper or mattress protector option out there that would optimize comfort and cooling, ideally also using wool/cotton? Or should I just try the mattress as is before assuming I want a topper? Based on testing firmer latex hybrids in stores I seemed to definitely prefer medium ones that had a couple more inches of latex on top.

2 Likes

Do you have a mattress protector you recommend that doesn’t mess with the bed?

2 Likes

Quite the research project! We make a 100% cotton knit fitted washable cover. Think a stretchy, lightweight, sweatshirt material. This is fully washable and dryer friendly, cut to easily fit 9"-14", give or take. There’s no wool in the protector, as it’s hard to reconcile that with washability, and also the stretchability of the cover (wool is in the quilting of the mattress anyway). This cover would be good for any knit covered mattress that was also quilted with a knit backing (many knits are backed with a non-stretchy layer). Best! :slight_smile:

1 Like

Thanks for the info! I wish I lived closer, but not sure I can make the three hour drive anytime soon. How often do y’all ship to outside of the Bay Area, and are you able to help dial in an ideal mattress to someone sight unseen? I’m still very curious about European sleep works, but worry that by the time shipping costs add up we might be priced out, and also concerns if we needed to swap something out.

1 Like

Still evaluating options, and I’m wondering if there is a way to get dual comfort in Cal King size? I see you offer a split king, but trying to figure out options to have different comfort in Cal king has proven hard, as adding a twin xl topper to one side ends up being a bit wide and short.

1 Like

All good points. We ship a fair bit, and deliver to a pretty wide area, but the level of service we expect to give does get more difficult. We are pretty good at helping with the selection, and because the topper is separate, we can start with a more conservative guess and then add if desired. Best of luck! I haven’t felt the Engineered Sleep Stuff, but the concept is solid (and for the 100th time, make sure the platform or foundation is bulletproof and you should be good).

1 Like

Hi @Lannalab - yes we can do this. Just reach out to our main number 866-244-0898 (call or text). It would be the same price as a Split-King.

1 Like

After way too much overthinking and evaluating options, I think a split cal king from SleepEZ might be our best bet. My thoughts are that having separate mattresses would help greatly with motion isolation, latex with a wool topper for temperature regulation, and the peace of mind of the adjustability of the sides independent of each other. Also knowing there are many places where I can get a half cal king topper if I end up needing a little more plushness on my side is comforting. Planning to get their Terra base with legs so I can attach my headboard and get rid of our creaky metal frame I’ve never liked.

Given our comfort needs and previous issues, does anyone see any glaring problems with this plan?

Thanks so much! Thankful to have found TMU, despite it leading me to do wayyy more research in purchasing a mattress.

1 Like

Hi @Lannalab,sounds like you’ve done a lot of research.Given your needs, a hybrid latex mattress with a medium-firm feel seems like a good balance, support for your husband’s side sleeping and enough give for your back/side combo. I like the idea of a separate topper too especially for longevity and easier replacement.

Brands like SleepEZ, Engineered Sleep and European Sleep offer adjustable or wool topped options that help with heat regulation. Medium is usually a safe choice for mixed sleepers with different weights but if your husband prefers firmer, a slightly firmer mattress with a soft wool or latex topper could be perfect. Definitely check return policies before committing.

1 Like

Thanks! I realize I didn’t clarify, but I was thinking all latex now as opposed to latex hybrid, since we could get separate side by side mattresses, or separate layers under one zip cover. I think I worry a bit about motion isolation with the all latex option, and I worry about it being too firm with the hybrid option. European sleep looked great, but my risk aversion and needing to pay shipping both ways means I could be out a lot of money if it didn’t work out. Trying to keep the mattress or mattress and topper in the 2K range to account for now also getting a new foundation.

3 Likes

It sounds like you’re both stuck in that ā€œtoo firm without a topper, too soft with oneā€ cycle. Given your weights and positions, a true medium latex hybrid is probably the right middle ground — especially since you liked the Avocado medium in store. At 135 lbs, you need enough surface give for shoulders/hips, while your husband at 210 lbs still needs solid support underneath.

1 Like

Hi Lannalab! I actually purchased the Avocado green last July, and sadly hated it. Worst mattress I’ve ever tried to sleep on lol Their customer service was great though, and they let me return it after the 30 day trial period. I’m actually filming a video now with my experience and review to put on YouTube, as this has been a serious project over the past year and I think I finally have it dialed in- fingers crossed! I will say I do love the Avocado 3" medium topper. I’ve been sleeping on that with a SOL firm 3" underneath for almost 8 months on the floor, but have my new Mattress Makers San Diego mattress arriving soon. I know a good quality latex mattress can last 20 years if cared for properly, so it may be an initial investment, but worth it!

I hope you find the perfect set up for you and your husband soon ā—”Ģˆ

2 Likes

Thanks for the info! Glad it sounds like you found something you will like. I’m waiting for my husband to finish building a simple sturdy platform bed and then plan to order. I’m hoping to love latex but I’m pretty concerned now that the motion transfer will be a problem. I am sensitive to feeling wiggled and jostled, and he often gets up about 40min-1hour before me and I often lose that last hour of sleep from feeling jostled. I was planning to do the sleepez organic hybrid with all split layers, but I still worry I’ll feel little vibrations. Then I was wondering if a thinner medium SOL mattress with the sleepez topper with the wool and split firmness might reduce motion transfer if there are more layers of non latex between main portion of the mattress and the topper. Do you have any thoughts on that given your experience with latex and SOL? There’s also always two separate mattresses, but we worry they will slide around.

3 Likes

Since I sleep alone so I may not be the best to ask on this topic, but the motion transfer on the mattress I chose is practically non existent, I couldn’t believe it! The manager/salesman in the store jumped on the other side to demonstrate this, and I didn’t feel anything lol That mattress is all Talalay latex from Mattress Makers. Are you set on what you are going to order or still figuring it out?

1 Like