Hi. I was here a few weeks ago looking into toppers. It was pointed out that there wasn’t really a topper that would solve the problem of my too-soft, squishy, broken-in memory foam bed. I appreciated the help and the honesty.
After a few talks with my husband, we both agree that it’s high time we choose a new mattress, for both our sakes. He’s particularly interested in an adjustable bed frame, as he has obstructive sleep apnea and sleeps better/has fewer apnea issues when he’s somewhat upright for sleep. So we’ll be looking into adjustable beds as well.
Over the weekend, we went into a few local mattress shops. If the names are at all familiar, we went into Orange Mattress, Shovlin, and Ethical Mattress, all in NJ. All had helpful staff who gave us info and patiently waited while we lay on a variety of beds. I was initially thinking our best best would be a hybrid latex/springs option, but my husband surprised me by preferring the all-latex models. Which I am fine with, as I found the latex beds very comfortable, and I know that latex should last us a long time!
Important things to note about us for mattress-making purposes. I’m 49. I run extremely hot and have basically been suffering/sweating/not sleeping much for years on our current memory foam mattress. I’m about 5’2, 200ish lbs. Curvy - think a generous hourglass shape. I’m primarily a side sleeper, but I also sleep a portion of the night on my stomach, and most often find that I relax best so I can fall asleep when I’m on my belly. I’ve had lifelong sleep issues and have struggled with insomnia for decades now, on top of my issues with running super hot. My hips are slightly out of alignment, per an xray run by my chiropractor. Did treatments, did some PT, pretty sure that’s still an issue, as I have chronic lower left back pain where my backside meets my back. I prefer a supportive mattress that has some cushion for comfort, but ultimately holds me up. My husband is 53. He feels more reasonably warm in his sleep. He radiates heat that makes me feel like I’m in a toaster! But he isn’t bothered by it. He’s 5’6, ~220lbs. He primarily sleeps on his back, though he should be sleeping on his side to help relieve his sleep apnea. With an adjustable base, he will likely sleep on his back with his head elevated. He prefers a softer mattress overall, but that may not actually be what’s best for him, given his apnea and his own sore spots (occasional pain/stiffness in back/neck/shoulder).
We know we want all-natural materials, for the sake of breathability/heat dispersal, as well as for environmental impact. Shovlin has a lovely all-Talalay latex option that comes wrapped in a polyblend encasement. Seems to me to be a waste. Ethical Mattress had a few good options (they sell Avocado beds, as well as the owner’s own designs). The one we liked best had the following stats, per the owner:
- stretch knit cotton w/ wool wrap around entire mattress
- 4" Organic Dunlop 48 ILD
- 4" Organic Dunlop 36 ILD
- 3" Organic Dunlop, Zoned 55k / 16 ILD
He told us this came to a total of 10" depth. (Though it seems to add up to 11", so I’m a bit confused by that.) We added a 2" medium density Avocado topper to this, and it was pretty darn good. I initially tried the 2" plush topper from Avocado, but I bottomed out on it, and I think my husband did too. I’d be happy to use a 3" topper if necessary, so long as what’s underneath is suitably firm and supportive for our various needs.
For breathability, though, I’d been hoping for Talalay latex, at least in the comfort layers. I understand that is the more breathable option due to the more even construction of the foam.
Is there a way to order something similar (doesn’t have to be completely identical, but somewhat similar density/firmness, only Talalay instead of Dunlop) from one of the Trusted Members here? Or at least, Talalay for the upper layers? Would this mean going the DIY route? (Again, relying on the TMs for the layers?)
Or would Talalay give us a totally different experience compared to similarly firm Dunlop? (We lay on two all-Talalay mattresses in various places - one was definitely firm enough, the other was too soft and I couldn’t get my body in alignment when I lay down. I do not have the ILDs for those.) We’d need a fully split king (two Twin XLs) so my husband can raise his head to whatever level helps him sleep without apnea incidents while I am somewhat more moderate in my positioning needs. We’d be happy to buy toppers to add a bit of plushness and extend the life of our mattresses, but would also be happy to have everything within the encasement, if we can find the right combination of layers for that.
Our budget isn’t unlimited, but we’ll either find a way to finance or cover the costs, because this is an investment in our quality of life. And I am so tired of rarely sleeping…
Please help?