Here is an easy chart comparison of the mattresses you selected.
| Feature |
BR800 Plush Pillow Top |
Sealy Satisfied II Soft Euro Top |
BRS900 Plush (Not Pillow Top) |
BRS900-C Plush (With or Without Pillow Top) |
BR Harmony Beachfront Bay (Not Pillow Top) |
BR Pressure Smart Plush (Not Pillow Top) |
| Comfort (Softness) |
Soft |
Medium-Soft |
Medium-Soft |
Medium-Soft |
Soft |
Soft |
| Pillow Top |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes/No |
No |
No |
| Coil Count |
Moderate |
High (typically) |
High |
High |
Low |
Moderate/High |
| Key Features |
Plush feel with cushioning |
Soft Euro top, solid support |
Plush feel, firmer base |
Plush with or without pillow top, flexible |
Softer feel, lower coil count, less support |
Pressure relief, moderate softness |
| Ideal For |
Those who prefer soft, cushioned feel |
Those who want softness with good support |
Those who prefer soft feel but without extra cushion |
Those who want flexibility between soft and firm |
Those looking for comfort, willing to compromise on support |
Those needing soft comfort with pressure relief |
One of the concerns with many of these mattresses is durability and long-lasting comfort. Many use viscoelastic memory foam and foam edge support in their construction. While this type of memory foam can provide some of the softness you’re looking for, it can also trap heat, which might be uncomfortable during sleep. The Sealy, on the other hand, offers solid edge-to-edge coil support, making it a more durable option. While it may feel slightly firmer than some of the others, it is likely built to last longer.
Regardless of how soft the top layer feels, it’s essential to have robust support beneath it. Without sufficient support, a mattress could cause issues like “hammocking” when back sleeping or strain on back muscles when stomach sleeping. Since your child is a side sleeper, the Sealy could be a great choice among the ones you’re considering.
However, since this is for a child, the age and stage of development are important factors. For children in their teens or younger, medium-firm to firmer mattresses are generally recommended. This is true for most kids, and particularly as they grow. Your child might love a softer mattress now, but it may not be the best option for their growing body over time.
With that in mind, I would also suggest considering the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid in Medium with the pillow top option, or the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora in Medium with the cloud top option. Both mattresses offer softer top layers that provide comfort without being too soft, while still maintaining the supportive foundation necessary for healthy growth.
Another solid option is the DLX Classic Hybrid in Medium, which features a softer comfort layer. It’s an extremely durable, long-lasting mattress that offers superior support, while the softer comfort layer ensures comfort without sacrificing support as your child grows into adulthood.
Children have different mattress needs due to their health and growth, and it’s important not to get them accustomed to something that’s too soft for their developing body. You want a mattress that offers both comfort and proper support, ensuring they sleep well while promoting healthy growth.
I know it is temping to when a child says they “love” your mattress, or sleeps soundly, but he is growing and they need support and good posture and alignment from their mattress. This needs to be paramount in your search.
Hopefully this gives you a bit more insight to what direction you should be going with the youngsters mattress.
Maverick