I very much liked that Naturepedic EOS Classic in the 8" plush coil + 3" firm dunlop, which I tried in store. I liked it even more with a 1.5" wool topper, but I feel that I would wait until the break in period before deciding to add that. But in my mind I keep coming back to what at least on paper seems like could be a similar configuration in the Natural Escape. The biggest differences I see are the zoned coils in the Natural Escape (Naturepedic=no zoning) and the button tufting (Naturepedic=no tufting). Short of that, both mattresses/manufacturers seem to share the same certifications (GOTS, GOLS, etc). Given that I canāt compare coil gauges or latex IDL, am I comparing apples to oranges? Iād be looking at the full size for a solo sleeper.
Truthfully, if the EOS was several hundred less, itād be a no brainer for me since I would prefer something I actually tried not to mention I was very impressed by the store proprietor and would be happy to give him my business. Not everyone will spend 2+ hours with you, answering every conceivable question. This was much more than I got at any other store.
But alas, the price differential is pretty big. Not knowing the Natural Escape, even if I wound up needing to buy the 2" topper, itās less costly than the EOS. Of course right now, Natural Escape is discounted, as is the EOS. The EOS is also including a lot of āfreebiesā that I wouldnāt mind but that arenāt my biggest priority, and I feel like even adding them as add-ons, the Nature Escape is less expensive (a set of sheets, two latex pillows, waterproof cotton mattress pad). Furthermore, Natural Escape has a 120-day sleep trial. Full refund or exchange. On the EOS, itād be 60-days to make a layer exchange but no refunds.
If money was no object, but of course it is. ~$2400 vs ~$1400 (mattress, topper, protector). Besides cost, is there anything Iām missing in my thought process? Flip a coin? At first my sleeplessness was due to my current mattress; now itās due to a tenacious bout of analysis paralysis. Help!