I’m jumping down the DIY rabbit hole and came across this guide: https://www.reddit.com/r/MattressMod/comments/1ccvych/an_updated_guide_to_mattress_diy/ . It mentions a lot of different materials that I’ve never heard of. I’ve also been looking into higher end mattresses and seeing what they use, like temper and purple. @Maverick also mentioned horse hair being an interesting pick as well. Are there any materials being used right now that are considered “state of the art” in the industry? For that matter, are there any materials that are currently being experimented with right now that could make for a better bed? If I did go down the DIY route: would I be able to source these materials easily?
1 Like
I think the term “state of the art” can mean a lot of different things depending on who you’re asking. Marketers, engineers, and DIYers are all going to have their own interpretations. Most mainstream mattress companies love to throw that phrase around, especially when it comes to cooling tech, gel infusions, or proprietary foams. You’ll see things like phase change materials, copper or graphite infusions, and zoned support layers marketed as cutting-edge. But the question is are they truly revolutionary, just clever packaging of small improvements, or using something created for another industry and attempting to adapt it in another?
There’s definitely some skepticism in the DIY and enthusiast circles about whether these features actually translate to a significantly better sleep experience, or if they’re just gimmicks with fancy names. For example, gel-infused memory foam sounds impressive, but a lot of people find the cooling effect minimal in practice. I agree, if you leave the mattress uncovered in a cold room, some of these cooling fabrics do, in fact, feel very cool or cold to the touch. The question remains, how long does it last, and when you begin to add, toppers, protectors, sheets and other bedding, does it move the needle at all.
That said, there are some legitimately innovative materials being explored, especially in niche or luxury segments. Companies like Tempur and Purple are experimenting with things like hyper-elastic polymers and high-density, temperature-sensitive foams. There may be value in them, but what is their longevity. Purple has be having a hell of a time with durability and even comfort.
While old fashioned is not always better in everything, I mean, who wants to go back to roll up windows in a car, right. Then again, as vinyl record audiophile, I still love the sound of music played on my 1970’s turntable.
Natural materials are also making a comeback. Like I mentioned, horsehair is interesting for its breathability, durability, moisture control and it’s something you still see in high-end handmade mattresses.
Latex, especially Talalay or organic Dunlop, remains a strong performer in both comfort and sustainability, and is often considered a top-tier material for DIY projects.
If you do go down the DIY route, sourcing depends on what you’re looking for. Basic components like memory foam, latex, and wool batting are fairly easy to find online through places like @DIYMattress and other online sellers. Although it can get tricky. Some folks will order a 5lb layer of memory foam, expecting to get a Tempurpedic firmness layer, and end up with a soft mushy foam. Sure it is durable at the 5lb designation, but density does not determine firmness, it can get tricky.
And then there’s the whole DIY thing. Doing it yourself might seem like the easiest or cheapest way to go, but it can get tricky without help from folks who really know mattresses, like the people at @Sleep_EZ or @Arizona_Premium.
They work with this stuff every day, so they understand how all the materials, like wool, cotton, latex, and how the different kinds of bases work together. If you’re new to all this, figuring out things like what kind of cover to use (stretchy or quilted), which layers go where, or whether you even need springs, base layer or a transition layer and the best foundation for the diy combination can get pretty confusing. But for someone who does this all the time, it’s just part of the job.
I’ve got this Perfectly Snug Smart Topper, and I have to say, it’s a pretty cool piece of tech. I guess you could call it “state of the art” in a way. It tracks your body temperature while you sleep and adjusts to match your sleep cycle, which can really help you sleep better. It doesn’t rely on fancy gels or high-tech materials, just smart innovative design that works with your body’s natural rhythm. Is it cutting-edge? Maybe, maybe not, I don’t know. But it does exactly what it says it will, and that’s what really matters.
Just my thoughts on the subject.
Maverick
1 Like
I totally agree with Maverick. If it is not a latex foam then it’s a polyurethane foam, made by the reaction of different isocyanates and polyols with added chemicals that can change the structure, density, and ILD of the foam.
1 Like
If the similarities are so slim, then why are brands like tempur or purple keeping a choke hold on their patents?
Tempurpedic is the best memoey foam. Purple does have an outstanding initial feel and pressure relief, but support is lame and ot breaks down.
John
So buckling gel is overrated then?
1 Like
Cutting Open a Purple Mattress with Spencer and Joe - YouTube
This is what you end up with when you opt for the purple buckling hyper elastic grid.
The concept seemed sound which is why I was interested in it, but yeah it doesn’t look all that durable. Although, I wonder if you can stack them to make a stronger array 
1 Like
In some of their newer models, the have placed the grid deeper into the mattress. Which kind of defeats the original purpose.
There was a better company that had buckling gel columns….Intellibed. I think Purple bought out Intellibed.
I think Intellibed is still being sold in Ontario, CA at Mathis Home.
I think Intellibed was better than Purple.
John