New Original Mattress Factory latex mattress: better or worse?

Mattress Talk General Mattresses Questions
1

The Original Mattress Factory recently changed the construction of their latex mattress.

Old

1 1/2" Convoluted Talatech® Talalay Latex Foam Topper – 17-21 ILD, 3.1-3.3lb Density
6" Talatech® Talalay Latex Foam Core - 30-34 ILD, 3.9-4.2lb Density
1 1/2" Convoluted Talatech® Talalay Latex Foam Topper – 17-21 ILD, 3.1-3.3lb Density

New

3" Talatech® Talalay Latex Foam Topper - Dual Comfort Foam Topper - (16-22 ILD, 3.0 lb density, 21-27 ILD, 3.25 lb density)
4 1/2" High Density Polyurethane Foam Core - 26-34 ILD, 2.5 lb Density
3" Talatech® Talalay Latex Foam Topper - Dual Comfort Foam Topper - (16-22 ILD, 3.0 lb density, 21-27 ILD, 3.25 lb density)

Here’s a pic of the new one: Imgur: The magic of the Internet

My wife and I liked and had been planning on purchasing the old one, which is still available for purchase for a limited time. The new one came out on Friday.

After reading a lot of info on this forum, the poly core of the new one worries me.

Two questions:

  1. Should we get the old one while we still can?
  2. If for some reason we end up not being able to buy the old version, does the construction of the new one raise any red flags?

Much appreciated,
Sleepless in Minnesota

Edit: I should also mention that the new one is almost $400 more.

2

I would suggest going with the old one if those are your only 2 options.

3

Hi yirmiyahu,

The new Serenity Latex has a different “feel” and design from the old Latex Supreme and for lack of a better word the new one feels firmer or more “substantial” (that’s how it was described to me). The old one was fairly soft compared to many other latex choices.

Both of them have no weak links in the mattress so from a durability point of view both would be good choices (2.5 lb polyfoam is a high quality material and the comfort layers are the most significant factor in the durability of a mattress).

In terms of material value … the old one had 9" of latex (3" of it was convoluted on each side) and was $1559 in queen (mattress only) and the new Serenity has 6" of latex (3" on each side) and a core of high quality polyfoam and is $1449 in a queen so they are very close although in terms of “raw material value” I would probably give the slight edge to the old Latex Supreme but the new one may be a design that more people would prefer. With the new Serenity you are also sleeping more directly on the latex which would be more contouring because the Latex Supreme had 1.5" of polyfoam in the quilting of the mattress. The cover of the Serenity is also a good quality stretch knit vs the Damask (less stretchy) in the Latex Supreme

The raw material cost of a mattress though is only part of the “value” of a mattress and the differences are small enough that I would choose the one that was the best match for you in terms of PPP and your “personal value equation” because both of them are good quality/value choices and the one that “sleeps” the best for you would be the better choice IMO.

Phoenix